Part of Temporal Constructs Appendix, which contains details behind the research: dates, quotations, descriptions of instruments, and sources.

General definition

The three tests keep the framework’s seven concepts apart. Each test asks one question:

  • Substitution, which asks what disappears if the concept is removed.
  • Tense, which asks which time the concept’s knowledge sits in.
  • Kind, which asks what sort of thing the concept is.
    Three tests keep the concepts apart, and the overlaps show where those tests strain.

Relation to the practice

The page sets out the tests in full, with the overlaps that show where the tests strain. The concepts themselves are on Distributed knowledge in Conductor.

Distinguishing the concepts

The first test is substitution, which turns on what disappears if the concept is removed. Hardware makes the sound, and without it there is none. Protocol addresses the parameters, and without it nothing can be mapped. The device turns saved settings into events, and the controller joins device and hardware into one surface. Presets spare every choice from being made again.

The timeline orders events, and context keeps what the work has accumulated. Tense turns on which time the knowledge sits in, and the timeline looks forward. A preset notes a decision already made, and context keeps what has been encountered and still shapes the present.

Kind turns on what sort of thing the concept is. The protocol is a specification, the controller a map, the device a rule, the preset a state and the timeline a plan. The context is a record that stays active.

The riskiest overlaps are the device with the timeline and the preset with context. In both cases the two can look alike on the surface. A device and a timeline both change what is heard, and the difference is authorship. A change placed at a point in time is part of the timeline, and a change produced by a rule at run time is part of the device.

A preset and context both retain what has already happened, and the difference is recall. A preset is called on deliberately, and context acts without being recalled. The source document tests every pair, and these two pairs need explicit treatment.

Unforeseen

Here the unforeseen situations, sometimes difficult, sometimes unexpectedly interesting, will be described as the project runs. Many of these unforeseen situations have already occurred and have been recorded. They will be added in the time to come.