Part of Temporal Constructs Main Text, which states the research questions, the proposals, the work done and what is still open.
General definition
Research is the systematic investigation of a question, conducted so that each claim it makes can be checked against evidence. It states what is investigated, what is to be established, and what would count as an answer. A claim that cannot be checked by anyone else is not a research result.
Relation to the practice
This doctorate investigates one problem: creative practitioners lose the ability to think with their tools. The instruments of the MIDI era, the years from 1983 to the late 1990s in which records were made over MIDI, hold collaborative principles that are being forgotten. The section sets out the objective, the principal question and its subsidiary questions, and the concepts the argument rests on, among them Creative agency, Co-creativity and creative intelligence. creative intelligence is read here as an improvisational correspondence between artists, agents, instruments and materials.
Three parts: authorship, the economics of creative work, and sustainability.
Problem
The research addresses one problem. It was found that practitioners are losing the ability to think with their tools, because systems that decide for them replace the instruments they can understand.
Authorship is one side of it. Instrument designers, the makers of presets and the agents that operate the machines all contribute to one work, which leaves the author unclear. The economics of creative work is another, and the field documents it itself. CISAC estimates that creators could lose 24 per cent of their revenues by 2028.
Sustainability is the third, and it is examined in three forms: ecological, cultural and social. The cultural form is about keeping operational knowledge alive in working systems. The social form is about whether creative work can remain sustainable under the pressure to delegate. The ecological form is about closed-source artificial intelligence tools, in energy footprint and in access.
An audiovisual laboratory, mediated by AI.
Objective
The objective of the research is an audiovisual laboratory, mediated by AI. In the laboratory the practice investigates creative intelligence in the relation between a creative person and a machine. It follows the example of the industrial laboratories where artists and engineers worked side by side. The starting point is that knowing a tool well is what turns it into a creative partner.
The problem is studied through the works made in the laboratory and through the tools built for those works. The results are not limited to artworks. The doctorate also writes papers and practice-based publications, documents the tools it builds, records performances, and keeps a living archive.
One principal question, still being revised, and five subsidiary questions.
Research question
The research is framed by the principal question, which is still being revised:
‘What form of creative intelligence surfaces when artists and AI agents create within the rule-based instruments of the MIDI era, preserving digital heritage through AI-extended active use, and what makes this practice transferable to other practitioners?’
The question is divided into five subsidiary questions. The first concerns design rationale. It asks what the designers of the MIDI era understood about working with a machine, and how much of that was deliberate. The second concerns shared mental models and overload. It asks what the machines of the MIDI era demanded of attention.
The third concerns agency and authorship. It asks who the author is when instrument designers, preset creators, collaborators and agents all contribute. The fourth concerns transferability. It asks what made these instruments obsolete, and whether AI can make them useful again without specialist knowledge. The fifth concerns visual music. It asks what an obscure and commercially unsuccessful light synthesiser can reveal about building an instrument for visual music.
A proposition to be tested in the practice.
Thesis
The thesis of the doctorate is the Redistribution Thesis, stated as a proposition to be tested in the practice, so a qualified or a negative result is also a valid outcome. The capacity to make consequential creative decisions is redistributed among the participants, and the artist steers that distribution rather than holding it in reserve. Its object of study is the co-creative relations between artists and AI agents. The forms of creative intelligence that appear within and between those relations are read as an improvisational correspondence. What is redistributed in them is creative agency. The relation between the practice and its instruments is understood as a conversation.
The works the argument rests on, and how much of each has been read.
Literature
The published work the research draws on is on Literature. It holds the works the argument is built on, the interviews and panels that are part of the research, and the sources cited on individual pages. Each source page records how much of the original has been read. Not every source cited in the archive has been checked against its original yet.
Gardner’s own claims, mostly untested, and a working framework of four kinds of knowledge.
Positions and framework
The claims of the practice are gathered as positions. They are Gardner’s own claims and open questions, and most of them are still to be tested. The research also uses a working framework of distributed knowledge, which sorts the knowledge built into a creative system into four kinds: what is possible, what acts, what was chosen and what is remembered.
Added as the research runs.
Unforeseen
Here the unforeseen situations, sometimes difficult, sometimes unexpectedly interesting, will be described as the project runs. Many of these unforeseen situations have already occurred and have been recorded. They will be added in the time to come.
Seven optional pages.
Related topics
The following pages are part of this section but are not needed to understand it. They can be opened from here for further exploration.