Part of Temporal Constructs Appendix, which contains details behind the research: dates, quotations, descriptions of instruments, and sources.
General definition
One of the questions that follow from a doctoral project’s principal question, dividing it into parts that can each be investigated and answered.
Relation to the practice
What did the designers of the MIDI era understand about working with a machine, and how deliberate was it? The research uses oral history with designers and early users to decide whether what transfers to AI agents is design understanding or coincidence, and its concept is Design rationale.
Their intention is present in every detail of the experience, from the mouse as a control interface to the small rule sets that memory limits forced. The question is whether these were models of composition or consequences of the hardware, which the artefacts alone cannot show.
Method of enquiry
The enquiry proceeds through interviews with designers and early users across competing design traditions. It also reads the artefacts for the design intention behind every detail. Neither source is sufficient alone, so the research puts the question to both.
Rosenboom’s account of HMSL
The account that bears on this question is Rosenboom’s, given in the interview recorded for the research. His answer is the deliberate one, at least for HMSL. He had wanted. The 1960s to build compositional procedures into the structure of instruments. The hierarchy he designed for the Touché, and later brought into HMSL, was chosen for generality.
Memory did constrain the work, and he names its cost in circuit boards of eight kilobytes. He describes the brevity of the rule set as an intention, and he built the models to be maximally applicable to any kind of music. He calls the language a tool and an artwork.
Constraint and intention
Limited memory forced designers to consider optimal use. Using little of it well forced the rule-based systems to state their rules. That allowed a person, and now an agent, to work within them. Hardware restriction turned these machines into knowable instruments. A person can relate to such an instrument in full, with a map of possibilities legible before any decision is made. Software built for a very large number of users and uses makes that harder to reach.
The divergence matters for this question. Once hardware allowed far more than developers used, designers were no longer forced to design with the same intention. The intention visible in the earlier instruments is a response to constraint. It thinned where the constraint lifted. That is what makes the question of deliberateness answerable.
Unforeseen
Here the unforeseen situations, sometimes difficult, sometimes unexpectedly interesting, will be described as the project runs. Many of these unforeseen situations have already occurred and have been recorded. They will be added in the time to come.