Part of Temporal Constructs Appendix, which contains details behind the research: dates, quotations, descriptions of instruments, and sources.
General definition
The living archive is an archive kept in use and not preserved only for consultation. It contains the tools, practices and working knowledge of a community alongside the documents that record them. What was made can therefore be made again. The archive stays answerable to the people it came from.
Relation to the practice
The living archive brings together everything the research produces: the sessions with the pioneers, the compositions and performances, the code written in KML and HMSL, the results of the educational pilots and the studies of adoption. It exists to respond to the closing window the problem names. The working knowledge of the MIDI era disappears with the people who keep it.
Wolfgang Ernst gives the distinction a name. In Digital Memory and the Archive he writes that source-oriented stock and classical file-oriented archive practices yield to the use-oriented, “to be completed” dynarchive, an archive in flux and in formation rather than a stock of documents. The living archive is of that kind: it is kept working, and its holdings are added to while the run of the research continues.
Dumbarton Oaks, Beatrix Farrand and the First Nations Garden.
What living archives show
Dumbarton Oaks keeps its garden as an archive twice over: in the drawings, photographs and correspondence it holds, and in the garden itself. Thaïsa Way writes that the garden as a living archive is in dialogue with the documents, verifying or countering what was actually built and how it matured, and that only in living the design can its intentions be understood. The records can be read beside the thing, which is how this practice reads a composition beside a run of the instrument that plays it.
The garden cannot be catalogued and put away. Way writes that it “can’t be simply catalogued and carefully stored away but must be constantly re-evaluated, curated, and actively tended every season, every year, every century”. Beatrix Farrand put it plainly herself: “A garden is not a static object. … It must be constantly not only weeded and cared for, [but] … replanted from time to time in order, like the Red Queen in Alice, to stay in one place.” What is planted to her specification is kept, and where a plant has died a replacement is chosen that carries the intention further. The substitution rule of this archive is of that kind: what was made here can be made again without becoming a copy of itself.
The garden keeps its own decision-making as well. The Dumbarton Oaks archive holds more than 1,226 drawings and sketches and the correspondence of 1922 to 1947, among them the several options Farrand drew for each project so that her client could consider them carefully. The value is not only in what was built, since the rejected alternatives are where the judgement shows. The practice keeps its abandoned proposals beside the work that replaced them for the same reason.
Care is named here rather than assumed. Tending the garden is labour, done by gardeners, stone masons and curators, and the land under it carries earlier uses that were inscribed in it before any of them. Monika Kin Gagnon studies the First Nations Garden in Montreal as a living archive of the eleven First Nations it names, in a place whose colonial past is still being transformed. An archive of somebody’s material has to say who tends it and on what terms it holds what it holds, which is the work of the licensing and governance terms of this page.
From Bernstein’s 1998 essay to Appleton’s overview.
The garden metaphor
The closest reference, and the one generally credited as first, comes from hypertext rather than archival theory. It is Mark Bernstein’s essay “Hypertext Gardens: Delightful Vistas”, published by Eastgate Systems in 1998. In it Bernstein reexamines the navigation problem, and finds that early research overstated it: readers were not getting lost, and muddled writing was more likely to be the cause of confusion than the complexity of the links. He sets the garden as a cultivated middle ground between rigid structure and wilderness, which fits a linked archive that is moved through by curiosity. Mike Caulfield, writing in 2015, places the concept of the wiki gardener from the 1990s alongside Bernstein’s essay as the early sources of the metaphor.
The usual overview is Maggie Appleton’s “A Brief History and Ethos of the Digital Garden” (2020), where Bernstein’s essay of 1998 figures as well as Caulfield’s “The Garden and the Stream: A Technopastoral” of 2015. She describes digital gardens as collections of evolving ideas that are not strictly organised by their publication date. That is close to this archive, and the concept is already well known among users of Obsidian, the tool with which this archive is maintained. Hermes Agent comes with Obsidian skills, making it a useful research instrument. Many use the combination of Obsidian and Hermes agent, where an Obsidian archive can serve the role of a second brain to both users as well as the agents they work with.
On the archival side, scholars have treated real gardens as living archives, among them Monika Kin Gagnon on the First Nations Garden in Montreal and the Dumbarton Oaks garden archive, where the garden as a living archive is in dialogue with the documents.
Added as the research runs.
Unforeseen
Here the unforeseen situations, sometimes difficult, sometimes unexpectedly interesting, will be described as the project runs. Many of these unforeseen situations have already occurred and have been recorded. They will be added in the time to come.